From c60b8878dfbca617d05b222069b8063c0ddab64b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Mark Date: Tue, 19 May 2026 17:56:28 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20phase-01=20paused=20=E2=80=94=20Plan=200?= =?UTF-8?q?1-13=20closed;=2001-10=20+=2001-12=20plans=20ready;=20researche?= =?UTF-8?q?r=20pending?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Session arc: - Plan 01-13 UAT harness: closed at 285e46f (15/15 GREEN; Bug A + Bug B regression demos verified; operator UAT ack) - Save-stops-recording: fix→reversal cycle (operator preferred original always-on charter); Amendments 2+3 of 01-09-PLAN.md document both cycles - Designer handoff fully ingested + 9 brand decisions resolved + R2 Lora reply unblocks display font - Plan 01-10 (welcome tab) rewritten in place at 3a530c2 — design-swap-in-ready architecture - Plan 01-12 (Design Integration) created at 8d1c8fb — R2 Lora baked in; 7 waves - Plan 01-11 closed as spike-pivot at ba5474c — architectural learnings preserved - Distribution zip published at dist-archives/ (gitignored; INSTALL.md included) Pause state: - vitest 98/98 GREEN; npm run test:uat 15/15 GREEN; tsc + build clean - Working tree: M .gitignore (dist-archives entry; safe to commit next session) - HEAD: e035fd2 Remaining Phase 1 work captured in HANDOFF.json + .continue-here.md: - Re-spawn install-flow + auto-select researcher (529'd twice during session; API capacity issue) - Plan 01-10 executor - Plan 01-12 executor - Operator brand-fit UAT after 01-12 lands - Phase 1 closure markers + ROADMAP.md backfill Resume with /gsd-resume-work after /clear. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) --- .planning/HANDOFF.json | 91 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 91 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .planning/HANDOFF.json diff --git a/.planning/HANDOFF.json b/.planning/HANDOFF.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ae9b4af --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/HANDOFF.json @@ -0,0 +1,91 @@ +{ + "version": "1.0", + "timestamp": "2026-05-19T15:53:41Z", + "phase": "01", + "phase_name": "stabilize-video-pipeline", + "phase_dir": ".planning/phases/01-stabilize-video-pipeline", + "wave": "post-Plan-01-13", + "status": "paused", + "completed_this_session": [ + {"id": "01-13", "name": "UAT harness Approach B — 15/15 GREEN", "status": "done", "commit_range": "70f4f41..285e46f", "notes": "All 4 waves executed; A0-A14 GREEN; Bug A + Bug B regression-rewind demos verified; Plan 01-09 functional contract closed via harness PASS per Amendment 2; operator Task 9 acked 'all good' 2026-05-19"}, + {"id": "save-stops-fix-and-reversal", "name": "Save-stops-recording charter cycle (fix then reverse)", "status": "done", "commits": ["cd83eb0", "4f4c3e2", "2b6c24b", "89f3337", "285e46f", "6ac23fd", "7645765", "1baaf45", "e035fd2"], "notes": "Operator first reported SAVE doesn't stop as a bug; debug session fixed it (SAVE→IDLE per SPEC one-shot reading); operator then preferred original always-on charter; reverse debug session inverted the fix + locked the new charter via inverted tests + A14 harness inversion. Plan 01-09 carries Amendments 2 + 3 documenting both cycles. SPEC reading clarified: continuous capture is the canonical Phase 1 charter."}, + {"id": "designer-handoff-ingest", "name": "Designer team handoff v1 ingested + 9 brand decisions resolved", "status": "done", "commits": ["5efc2a8", "2669ce3"], "notes": "tokens.css + mokosh-mark.svg + mokosh-lockup.svg + Decision Brief + Surface Kit landed at .planning/intel/design-incoming/; brand-decisions-v1.md captures D-01..D-09 picks (designer recommendations accepted except D-07 = 'Mokosh — Session Capture'); designer follow-up #1 (Newsreader Cyrillic gap) resolved 2026-05-19 by R2 / substitute with Lora — tokens.css line: --mks-font-display: \"Lora\", \"Iowan Old Style\", \"Times New Roman\", serif"}, + {"id": "01-10-plan-rewrite", "name": "Plan 01-10 (welcome tab) rewritten in place per design-swap-in-ready arch", "status": "plan_only", "commit": "3a530c2", "notes": "Was originally drafted 2026-05-17 with REQUEST_PERMISSIONS references (since deleted in 01-09); rewritten to reflect D-02 Hero+Loom-dial layout + D-08 tagline + design-swap-in-ready (CSS variables, copy source-of-truth, hero slot) + harness A15+A16+A17. Executor pending."}, + {"id": "01-12-plan-create", "name": "Plan 01-12 (Design Integration) created with R2 Lora baked in", "status": "plan_only", "commit": "8d1c8fb", "notes": "7 waves, 10 tasks. Wave 0 Lora WOFF2 self-hosting (Cyrillic subset) + Wave 1 tokens.css → src/shared/ + Wave 2 SVG→PNG icon rasterization (replaces Bug A placeholders) + Wave 3 manifest i18n (__MSG_*__) + Wave 4 src/popup+welcome adopt tokens + Wave 5 8 i18n strings → _locales/{en,ru}/ + Wave 6 harness A18-A22 + Wave 7 operator brand-fit checkpoint. Executor pending."}, + {"id": "01-11-spike-pivot", "name": "Plan 01-11 closed as spike-pivot — Approach A falsified", "status": "done", "commit": "ba5474c", "notes": "Original architecture (Puppeteer sw.evaluate against MV3 SW) empirically falsified — MV3 SW blocks dynamic import; CDP attaches as generic worker without extension chrome.* surface. Approach B (extension-internal-page harness) proven by c647f61 prototype; full implementation moved to Plan 01-13. Lessons: never await import() in src/background/index.ts; track.dispatchEvent('ended') not track.stop(); __MOKOSH_UAT__ Vite define-token over import.meta.env.MODE."}, + {"id": "distribution-zip", "name": "Distribution artifact for tester install", "status": "done", "notes": "dist-archives/mokosh-build-2026-05-19-285e46f.zip (154 KB) + INSTALL.md (extraction + Load Unpacked instructions + known-limitations list). dist-archives/ added to .gitignore (modification uncommitted at pause). SHA256: e05ff3dff807a3c74cea6ac821d433c24de2e209803237413d12accbb3986ae0"} + ], + "remaining_tasks": [ + { + "id": "researcher-install-flow", + "name": "Spawn researcher for install-time auto-start + auto-select desktop UX asks", + "status": "blocked_pending_api_capacity", + "details": "User flagged 2026-05-19: (1) start recording at install time; (2) auto-select desktop (skip picker). Orchestrator pre-research hypotheses: Ask 1 = getDisplayMedia requires user gesture per W3C spec, achievable max is install→welcome-tab→single-button-click (zero-friction-as-possible); Ask 2 = picker is consent gate, achievable max via chrome.desktopCapture.chooseDesktopMedia(['screen']) or single-monitor auto-accept behavior. User policy: 'minimum friction everywhere' confirmed. Spawned twice during session; both hit 529 Overloaded (server-side API capacity). Brief is at the bottom of this HANDOFF.json under 'pending_researcher_brief'.", + "resume_with": "Spawn gsd-phase-researcher fresh with brief at .continue-here.md §'Pending Researcher Brief'; foreground (orchestrator awaits verdict to revise Plan 01-10 + possibly Plan 01-09 amendment + maybe Plan 01-12 manifest)" + }, + { + "id": "01-10-executor", + "name": "Execute Plan 01-10 (welcome tab) per 3a530c2 plan", + "status": "ready", + "details": "Plan is design-swap-in-ready; will use engineering placeholder tokens today and absorb Plan 01-12's canonical tokens.css when 01-12 lands. 4 autonomous tasks + 1 operator checkpoint (fresh-profile install verification). NOTE: post-researcher findings, Plan 01-10 may need amendment if 'install→start' becomes 'install→welcome tab with Start button that triggers picker' (changes CTA from informational to actionable).", + "resume_with": "Spawn gsd-executor with 01-10-PLAN.md (commit 3a530c2) as spec; foreground; per-wave fresh-context pattern not strictly needed for 01-10 (smaller scope than 01-13)" + }, + { + "id": "01-12-executor", + "name": "Execute Plan 01-12 (Design Integration) per 8d1c8fb plan", + "status": "ready", + "details": "R2 Lora unblocked; planner produced full spec. 7 waves include Lora WOFF2 self-hosting + SVG→PNG icons + tokens.css → src/shared/ + manifest i18n + popup/welcome adoption + 8 i18n strings + harness A18-A22 + operator brand-fit checkpoint. Touches manifest.json (potential parallel-execution conflict with 01-10 which also touches manifest.json — different keys though; sequential safer).", + "resume_with": "Spawn gsd-executor with 01-12-PLAN.md (commit 8d1c8fb); foreground; per-wave fresh-context recommended given scope (7 waves)" + }, + { + "id": "phase-1-closure", + "name": "Phase 1 final closure — flip REQUIREMENTS / ROADMAP / STATE markers after 01-10 + 01-12 land", + "status": "pending_dependencies", + "details": "Phase 1 functional contract already closed (01-13 harness PASS). Final closure needs 01-10 (welcome tab) + 01-12 (design integration) + operator brand-fit ack on the rendered tokens/icons/copy. ROADMAP.md gap (Plans 01-08..01-12 missing entries per Plan 01-13 plan-checker flag #4) is separate housekeeping.", + "resume_with": "After 01-10 + 01-12 executor return; /gsd-verify-work 1 goal-backward verification; then flip markers" + }, + { + "id": "phase-2-prep", + "name": "Phase 2 (Stabilize DOM + event-capture privacy) — kickoff prep", + "status": "pending_phase_1_closure", + "details": "Phase 2 owns rrweb + event-log + privacy hardening (audit P0 #6 currently leaks passwords + data-sensitive fields). Harness from 01-13 becomes closure-gate template for Phase 2 plans. Pattern: each new plan extends the harness with A18+ assertions for its surface." + } + ], + "blockers": [ + { + "description": "Anthropic API 529 Overloaded during researcher spawn (intermittent during 2026-05-19 afternoon session)", + "type": "external", + "workaround": "Retry on next session if API has recovered; user confirmed they're monitoring status" + } + ], + "human_actions_pending": [ + { + "action": "Designer responses to any remaining clarifications discovered during Plan 01-12 execution (e.g. Lora upstream source URL preference, default_locale 'en' vs 'ru' for Chrome Web Store metadata, exact Russian wording for manifest.json:name)", + "context": "Plan 01-12 RESEARCH §11 + Plan 01-12 plan §Open Questions enumerate 5 questions executor can usually resolve inline but may surface", + "blocking": false + }, + { + "action": "Brand team final wording for 8 operator-facing i18n strings (Brief §02)", + "context": "Plan 01-12 Wave 3 default-uses Sober register placeholders inheriting from D-03; brand team's final strings swap in via _locales/ when ready", + "blocking": false + } + ], + "decisions_this_session": [ + {"decision": "Plan 01-11 closed as spike-pivot (not amended-in-place) — new SUMMARY + new Plan 01-13 for the proven architecture", "rationale": "GSD lifecycle pattern: PLAN.md is forward-looking spec, not history. >50% architecture change requires new plan, not amendment. Established the spike-then-pivot framing as a legitimate plan outcome."}, + {"decision": "Save-stops-recording charter went through fix→reversal cycle in same session", "rationale": "Operator's first instinct was 'doesn't switch off = bug' but after living with the fix, preferred the original always-on safety net. Cycle preserved in Amendments 2+3 of 01-09-PLAN.md for audit trail; tests inverted (not deleted) to lock the new charter."}, + {"decision": "Plan 01-10 rewritten in place (not as new plan)", "rationale": "01-10 had never been executed (no commits, no SUMMARY); pre-execution PLAN.md can be revised freely per GSD lifecycle. Different from 01-11 case (which had executed partially)."}, + {"decision": "R2 Lora substitution chosen over R1 fallback chain", "rationale": "Designer decision; Lora has full Cyrillic coverage in a single variable font (~80-100KB); avoids mixed-glyph paragraph disharmony of R1; aesthetically pairs with Loom warm-linen palette."}, + {"decision": "Distribution zip published at dist-archives/ with INSTALL.md", "rationale": "Tester-install pathway; gitignored to avoid repo bloat; INSTALL.md documents current placeholder state so testers know what's pending vs shipped."} + ], + "uncommitted_files": [ + {"path": ".gitignore", "reason": "dist-archives/ ignore entry added during distribution-zip build; not yet committed; safe to commit as 'chore: gitignore dist-archives' in next session OR fold into next docs commit"} + ], + "session_anti_patterns_recurring": [ + {"name": "Improvised artifact types (AMENDMENT-A.md)", "severity": "resolved", "details": "Mid-session I created `.planning/phases/01-stabilize-video-pipeline/01-11-PLAN-AMENDMENT-A.md` without checking GSD artifact-types.md — it's not a recognized type. User pushed back; researched via planner-revision.md + artifact-types.md; established canonical patterns: surgical revisions for small changes (per planner-revision.md); new-plan-when-scope-shifts for >50% changes; in-place rewrite for un-executed plans. Plan 01-11 was closed as spike-pivot; AMENDMENT-A.md was deleted; lesson captured in 01-11-SUMMARY Architectural Notes. Should not recur if next session follows the established pattern."}, + {"name": "Claiming 'canonical' without verifying", "severity": "advisory", "details": "Twice this session I called something 'canonical' based on inference rather than checking the GSD docs (rewrite-in-place vs add-new-plan being the prime example). User caught it; corrected to actually read planner-revision.md + artifact-types.md. Pattern: when claiming GSD-canonical, cite a doc by path; don't infer."}, + {"name": "Save-stops UX cycle", "severity": "advisory", "details": "Operator's first report was 'doesn't switch off = bug'; I routed to /gsd-debug and shipped the fix; operator then realized original always-on was correct. Reverse debug session inverted everything. Lesson: when operator surfaces UX 'bug' that's actually charter-divergent (intentional behavior they observed but didn't expect), consider clarifying the charter intent BEFORE shipping a code change. Could have saved one cycle by asking 'is this a bug or unexpected behavior you'd like to confirm matches design intent?' before /gsd-debug."} + ], + "context_notes": "Phase 1 functional contract is closed via Plan 01-13's harness (npm run test:uat 15/15 GREEN). Remaining Phase 1 work is two parallel-able plans (01-10 welcome tab + 01-12 design integration) plus a researcher spawn that was 529-blocked for install-flow + auto-select UX asks. Designer ALL asks now answered (9 decisions + Lora R2). Tests + build + harness all GREEN at pause. Distribution zip published for tester install. Next session: re-spawn researcher (API permitting), then either execute 01-10 + 01-12 in parallel OR sequentially. The Plan 01-13 SUMMARY at 01-13-SUMMARY.md captures the full session arc including the save-stops cycle.", + "pending_researcher_brief": "See `.planning/phases/01-stabilize-video-pipeline/.continue-here.md` §'Pending Researcher Brief' — 12-area research scope covering: getDisplayMedia gesture verification empirical, enterprise policy reality (ScreenCaptureWithoutGestureAllowedForOrigins), welcome-tab Start-button gesture chain, chrome.desktopCapture.chooseDesktopMedia behavior, Chrome 2024-2026 API additions, single-monitor auto-accept empirical, industry prior art (Loom/Screencastify/etc.), permission combinations, welcome-tab + onStartup interplay, privacy/consent UX, recommended minimum-friction journey, edge cases (macOS permission, Linux Wayland/X11).", + "next_action": "After /clear: run /gsd-resume-work to load this HANDOFF.json. Recommended first step: re-spawn install-flow + auto-select researcher (the 529-blocked work) IF API is healthy; else proceed with Plan 01-10 executor OR Plan 01-12 executor (parallelizable on different surfaces; sequential for safety given prior background-spawn permission issue). All three workstreams (researcher, 01-10 executor, 01-12 executor) are independent inputs to Phase 1 final closure." +}