repremium/mokosh
2
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs(phase-03): VERIFICATION + Phase 3 closure markers — verdict PASSED (5/5 ROADMAP + 9/9 SPEC §10)

Browse Source 
Phase 3 verifier returned human_needed with 2 verification items:
1. §10 #9 RAM ceiling — genuinely non-automatable (Page.metrics page-realm only
   per RESEARCH Pitfall 2; SW heap unreachable in MV3 without research budget)
2. ROADMAP/STATE marker flips — orchestrator-owned per worktree protocol

Item 2 resolved automatically via gsd-sdk phase.complete:
- ROADMAP Phase 3 marker flipped [x]
- STATE.md completed_phases: 2 → 3; percent recalculated 75
- REQUIREMENTS.md REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer + REQ-user-event-log flipped Complete

Item 1 OVERRIDDEN to VERIFIED based on user explicit ack 2026-05-20:
- A32 best-effort scaffolding (page-realm Page.metrics with explicit "page-realm
  only" diagnostic; ~1.82 MB at harness baseline; harness self-leak detector)
- chrome://memory-internals operator instructions preserved in human_verification
  for spot-checks
- Alpha distribution build covers real-world cross-profile RAM observation
- D-P3-04 charter explicitly authorized best-effort + operator/alpha path
- Analogous to Phase 2 T5 override per saved memory
  feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md
- Programmatic SW-context measurement via chrome.devtools Memory API deferred
  to Phase 4 hardening (in 03-VERIFICATION.md Forward-Looking Deferred Items)

VERIFICATION.md frontmatter: status flipped human_needed → passed.
overrides_applied: 4 (3 from executor 03-05 + 1 for §10 #9 closure).

STATE.md body refreshed: Phase 3 marked COMPLETE with citations + Phase 4
character clarified (optional; milestone v1 may close at Phase 3); body
completed_plans bumped 18 → 23 (CLI bug auto-fix; 14 + 4 + 5 = 23).

PROJECT.md Validated section evolved: Phase 3 section added with REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer
+ REQ-user-event-log + §10 sweep entries; Active section restructured to show
Phase 4 backlog (12 deferred items) with milestone v1 close option called out.

Phase 3 closure: 5/5 plans landed; UAT harness 29→33 GREEN (A29 A30 A31 A32);
vitest 171/171 GREEN preserved; Tier-1 FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS 12; bundle gates
6/6 PASS; src/content/index.ts UNMODIFIED per D-P3-02 charter literal.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Mark
2026-05-20 21:36:06 +02:00
parent 4de6b3b9ae
commit d02b41b7c7
3 changed files with 332 additions and 213 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

489
.planning/phases/03-spec-10-smoke-verification-dom-event-log-verification/03-VERIFICATION.md
View File

@@ -1,204 +1,311 @@
---
phase: 03-spec-10-smoke-verification-dom-event-log-verification
verified: 2026-05-20T19:15:33Z
verified: 2026-05-20T22:00:00Z
status: passed
score: 9/9 SPEC §10 criteria
overrides_applied: 3
override_notes:
- dimension: "SPEC §10 #4 — rrweb DOM event capture on typical pages"
initial_status: "UNCERTAIN (human_needed candidate — would otherwise require operator UAT on form/table/modal page)"
override_to: "VERIFIED"
score: 5/5 ROADMAP success criteria (9/9 SPEC §10 criteria — 8 automated + 1 best-effort scaffolding with operator/alpha fallback)
overrides_applied: 4
re_verification:
previous_status: human_needed
previous_score: 5/5 with 2 human_verification items
gaps_closed:
- "ROADMAP Phase 3 marker flipped [x] via gsd-sdk phase.complete 2026-05-20T22:10Z"
- "STATE.md completed_phases bumped 2 → 3 + percent 78 → 75 via gsd-sdk phase.complete"
- "SPEC §10 #9 RAM ceiling — user explicit ack 2026-05-20 to close on A32 scaffolding + alpha distribution coverage path (analogous Phase 2 T5 override; per saved memory feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md)"
gaps_remaining: []
regressions: []
override_notes_phase_3_closure:
- dimension: "SPEC §10 #9 RAM ceiling ≤ 50 MB"
initial_status: "human_needed (Page.metrics page-realm only per RESEARCH Pitfall 2; SW heap genuinely unreachable in MV3 without research budget)"
override_to: "VERIFIED (best-effort coverage)"
rationale: |
User explicit delegation 2026-05-20 (saved memory feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md):
automation covers what automation can cover. Plan 03-01 ships A29 which empirically verifies
via Puppeteer-driven real Chrome:
- rrweb/session.json contains > 0 events (A29.2)
- EventType.Meta (=4) present (A29.3)
- EventType.FullSnapshot (=2) present (A29.4)
- EventType.IncrementalSnapshot (=3) present (A29.5)
The probe HTML at tests/uat/extension-page-harness.html provides form + table + modal
(RESEARCH Pitfall 4: NO textarea per rrweb 2.0.0-alpha.4 issue #1596). Plan 03-01 driveA29
injects a DOM mutation pre-SAVE so IncrementalSnapshot fires (RESEARCH Pitfall 1).
A29 GREEN: cc13f31 (Plan 03-01 Task 2 feat commit). Operator UAT for SPEC §10 #4 retired
per the same delegation; the harness IS the canonical §10 #4 verification.
Known follow-up: Plan 03-02 + 03-03 SUMMARYs disclosed an A29 ZIP-mtime race-condition
flake (chrome-extension:// has no content script; assertA29's harness-page-page.evaluate
misses on first attempt + findLatestZip non-deterministically returns either A29's own
empty zip OR a prior-stage zip with iana.org rrweb content). Empirically reproduces on
~1/3 of consecutive runs at HEAD; second consecutive run passes 33/33 GREEN. The fix is
mechanical (re-target A29 to use Plan 03-02/03's cs-injection-world pattern); deferred
to Phase 4 per scope-minimization charter. Tracked in Forward-Looking Deferred Items.
- dimension: "SPEC §10 #5 — event log captures clicks, navigation, network errors"
initial_status: "UNCERTAIN (human_needed candidate — would otherwise require operator UAT on probe page with synthetic triggers)"
override_to: "VERIFIED"
rationale: |
Same delegation as #4 (saved memory feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md). Plan 03-02
ships A30 which verifies all 5 UserEvent.type literal values are captured during a
synthetic-trigger drive:
- click (A30.2): chrome.scripting.executeScript ISOLATED-world injects .click() on a button
- input (A30.3): set input.value + dispatchEvent('input') inside ISOLATED world
- navigation (A30.4): window.dispatchEvent(new PopStateEvent('popstate')) exercises the
production popstate listener at src/content/index.ts:111 (functionally equivalent to
history.pushState/handleNavigation which would have destroyed Puppeteer's CDP context)
- js_error (A30.5): window.dispatchEvent(new ErrorEvent('error', ...))
- network_error (A30.6): fetch(https://example.com/<404-path>) intercepted at
src/content/index.ts:167 (production wrapper bound to content-script ISOLATED world)
All 5 triggers happen inside a fresh https://example.com probe tab (RFC 2606 reserved
domain) where the production content script attaches normally — cs-injection-world pattern
introduced by Plan 03-02 (chrome.tabs.create + chrome.scripting.executeScript {world:
'ISOLATED'}) because <all_urls> match pattern does NOT cover chrome-extension:// scheme.
A30 GREEN: 116432a (Plan 03-02 Task 2 feat commit).
- dimension: "SPEC §10 #8 — password masking (PARTIAL per D-P3-02 charter)"
initial_status: "PARTIAL"
override_to: "PARTIAL — VERIFIED-IN-SCOPE"
rationale: |
REQ-password-confidentiality moved Out of Scope v1 per 2026-05-20 charter shift
"we don't care about privacy hardening. At least here." (D-P3-02). Full rrweb v2
maskInputFn + data-sensitive HTML attribute guards DEFERRED to Phase 4 if charter
reverses.
Existing minimum at src/content/index.ts:82 (`if (target.type === 'password') return;`)
is VERIFIED by Plan 03-03 A31 (3 orthogonal-channel checks via the cs-injection-world
pattern + defense-in-depth control input):
- A31.2 — 0 UserEvent entries contain SENTINEL='secret-do-not-log-123' in their .value
field (proves the line-82 filter early-returned BEFORE addUserEvent)
- A31.3 — 0 UserEvent entries have target === '#probe-password' (filter early-returns
BEFORE addUserEvent)
- A31.4 — >=1 UserEvent entry contains the control sentinel typed into a non-password
text input in the same injection (defense-in-depth: proves the production listener IS
alive, so A31.2/A31.3 absences mean the filter fired — NOT "no events at all")
All three checks GREEN proves the line-82 filter fires AND the listener is alive.
A31 GREEN: 34b36fb (Plan 03-03 Task 2 feat commit).
Mark PARTIAL (not VERIFIED-FULL) because rrweb session.json could in principle
capture password-input characters via DOM mutation snapshots if maskInputOptions.password
ever regressed. Production wiring at src/content/index.ts:306 sets `password: true`
(rrweb v2 alpha.4 mask); A29 verifies rrweb records SOMETHING, not specifically
that masked-password content is absent. Phase 4 candidate task: extend A31 to also
grep rrweb/session.json for SENTINEL absence (one-line extension; not needed for
the existing-minimum PARTIAL charter).
User explicit ack 2026-05-20 to close on the A32 best-effort scaffolding + alpha
distribution coverage path. Three independent coverage layers ship from Phase 3:
(a) A32 puppeteer.Page.metrics() = page-realm JS heap measurement (~1.82 MB at
harness baseline) with explicit "NOTE: page-realm only" diagnostic emitted on
every run — verifies the harness itself doesn't leak; informational lower-bound
(b) chrome://memory-internals operator instructions documented in 03-VERIFICATION.md
human_verification entry (preserved for any operator who wants to spot-check)
(c) Alpha distribution build covers real-world cross-profile RAM observation in
operators' actual usage patterns
D-P3-04 charter explicitly authorized best-effort + operator/alpha note for §10 #9;
programmatic SW-context measurement via chrome.devtools Memory API deferred to
Phase 4 hardening (in CONTEXT.md deferred list).
accepted_by: "Mark (user explicit ack 2026-05-20 + D-P3-04 charter)"
accepted_at: "2026-05-20"
overrides:
- must_have: "SPEC §10 #4 — rrweb DOM event capture on typical pages"
reason: |
Plan 03-01 A29 GREEN (cc13f31): 4 EventType-enum checks against rrweb/session.json from
probe-HTML-driven archive (Meta=4, FullSnapshot=2, IncrementalSnapshot=3, count>0).
Probe HTML includes form + table + modal + DOM-mutation trigger per RESEARCH Pitfall 1.
Harness coverage canonical per saved memory feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md
(user explicit delegation 2026-05-20). Operator UAT retired by delegation.
accepted_by: "Mark (user explicit delegation 2026-05-20)"
accepted_at: "2026-05-20T00:00:00Z"
- must_have: "SPEC §10 #5 — event log captures clicks, navigation, and network errors"
reason: |
Plan 03-02 A30 GREEN (116432a): all 5 UserEvent.type literals verified (click, input,
navigation, js_error, network_error) via chrome.scripting.executeScript ISOLATED-world
on https://example.com probe tab (cs-injection-world pattern). Same delegation as #4.
accepted_by: "Mark (user explicit delegation 2026-05-20)"
accepted_at: "2026-05-20T00:00:00Z"
- must_have: "SPEC §10 #8 — passwords do not appear in the log or rrweb snapshots"
reason: |
Plan 03-03 A31 GREEN (34b36fb): PARTIAL per D-P3-02 charter shift 2026-05-20 ("we don't
care about privacy hardening. At least here."). Existing minimum at src/content/index.ts:82
(target.type === 'password' early-return) verified via 3-check sentinel absence pattern:
A31.2 (0 UserEvent.value contains SENTINEL), A31.3 (0 UserEvent.target === '#probe-password'),
A31.4 (>=1 control-sentinel event proves listener alive — defense-in-depth). REQ-password-
confidentiality moved Out of Scope v1. Full rrweb v2 maskInputFn deferred to Phase 4.
accepted_by: "Mark (charter shift 2026-05-20 + D-P3-02)"
accepted_at: "2026-05-20T00:00:00Z"
human_verification:
- dimension: "SPEC §10 #9 — Extension background RAM ≤ 50 MB"
rationale: |
Per D-P3-04 + RESEARCH Pitfall 2: puppeteer.Page.metrics() is PAGE-REALM ONLY.
The MV3 service worker lives in a separate Puppeteer target with its own V8
isolate; page.metrics() does NOT aggregate across workers/iframes. The
operator-driven chrome://memory-internals observation is the canonical §10 #9 gate.
Plan 03-04 ships A32 (Page.metrics scaffolding; UAT count 32 → 33 GREEN). A32 is
INFORMATIONAL only and emits the mandatory diagnostic `'NOTE: page-realm only;
SW context measurement requires chrome://memory-internals operator verification
per D-P3-04.'` on every run. Empirical run reports ~1.82 MB JSHeapUsedSize for the
harness page realm — well under 50 MB, but that is page-realm only and does NOT
close §10 #9 by itself. A32 GREEN: 8c94bd5 (Plan 03-04 Task 1 feat commit).
Operator verification steps (~3 min):
1. Load unpacked extension from dist/ into Chrome (chrome://extensions/,
Developer mode → Load unpacked → select dist/). Expected: no errors.
2. Start a recording (click Mokosh toolbar icon → "Entire screen").
3. Leave the recording running idle (no manual interactions) for ≥ 5 minutes.
4. Open chrome://memory-internals (preferred) OR chrome://extensions/ →
"Service worker" link → DevTools Memory tab.
5. Find the Mokosh extension entry. Read the "Service worker" memory value
(or the aggregated extension RAM from chrome://memory-internals if
available).
6. Expected: total < 50 MB. If > 50 MB, route via /gsd-debug per
feedback-gsd-ceremony-for-fixes.md (NO hot-edits).
Operator reply contract: type "approved §10 #9 — observed RAM <X> MB" or
describe deviation. The Operator-Empirical Acks table below records the result.
- test: "Navigate to chrome://memory-internals (or chrome://extensions → Service worker link → DevTools Memory tab). Find the Mokosh extension entry. Read the Service worker memory value."
expected: "Total extension background RAM < 50 MB after ≥ 5 minutes of idle recording."
why_human: "puppeteer.Page.metrics() is page-realm only (RESEARCH Pitfall 2). The MV3 service worker is a separate Puppeteer target with its own V8 isolate; page.metrics() does not aggregate across workers/iframes. A32 (8c94bd5) provides informational scaffolding (page-realm heap ~1.82 MB) but the SPEC §10 #9 operator gate requires chrome://memory-internals observation per D-P3-04."
- test: "Confirm ROADMAP.md Phase 3 row is flipped [x] and STATE.md completed_phases incremented to 3."
expected: "ROADMAP line 37 shows [x], progress table row 3 shows CLOSED 2026-05-20, STATE.md completed_phases: 3."
why_human: "Worktree parallel-executor protocol deliberately deferred these doc-only flips to the orchestrator post Wave-5 merge (documented in 03-05-SUMMARY.md key-decisions). The omission is known and intentional, not a code gap. Orchestrator must perform or confirm these two doc updates."
deferred:
- truth: "Programmatic SW-context RAM measurement"
addressed_in: "Phase 4"
evidence: "Phase 4 deferred items: 'Programmatic RAM measurement upgrade (per-target puppeteer.browser.targets() filter + createCDPSession() + Performance.getMetrics aggregation across SW + offscreen + page realms)'"
- truth: "A29 IncrementalSnapshot race-condition flake (hits ~1/3 of consecutive runs)"
addressed_in: "Phase 4"
evidence: "Phase 4 deferred items row 1: 'A29 zip-mtime race-condition flake (chrome-extension:// no-content-script; flaky on ~1/3 runs). Recommended fix: re-target A29 to use cs-injection-world pattern'"
- truth: "Full REQ-password-confidentiality (rrweb v2 maskInputFn + data-sensitive guards)"
addressed_in: "Phase 4 conditional"
evidence: "Phase 4 deferred items: 'REQ-password-confidentiality v2 candidate — only re-opens if charter reverses'"
---
# Phase 3: SPEC §10 smoke verification + DOM/event-log verification — Verification Report
**Phase Goal:** All 9 SPEC §10 acceptance criteria pass against an unpacked
load of the build into a real Chrome instance. Absorbs REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer
+ REQ-user-event-log verification per 2026-05-20 re-phasing (the original
Phase 2 was removed; DOM + event-log verification moved into this phase).
**Phase Goal:** All 9 SPEC §10 acceptance criteria pass against an unpacked load of the build
into a real Chrome instance. ABSORBS DOM + event-log verification work (REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer
+ REQ-user-event-log) originally planned as Phase 2 per 2026-05-20 re-phasing.
**Verified:** 2026-05-20T19:15:33Z
**Status:** passed (3 overrides applied — see override_notes; 1 entry in
human_verification block for SPEC §10 #9 RAM ceiling per D-P3-04 charter)
## Goal Achievement
### SPEC §10 Acceptance Criteria — Per-Criterion Scorecard
| # | Criterion (SPEC §10 verbatim) | Phase Owner | Evidence | Status |
|----|------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------|
| 1 | Extension installs in Chrome without errors | Phase 1 | Plan 01-12 closure + operator brand-fit ack 2026-05-20 "all good" (commit f319c7d); Plan 01-10 cycle-2 ack "All good" 2026-05-20 (commit d1ef77a); tests/build/no-remote-fonts.test.ts + tests/i18n/manifest-i18n.test.ts + tests/i18n/locale-parity.test.ts GREEN; Phase 1 closure 586836f | PASS |
| 2 | Video buffer runs continuously on any tab | Phase 1 | Plan 01-07 closure (commit cd61cbc) + A2/A11 harness GREEN (35s buffer-continuity wait); src/offscreen/recorder.ts D-13 restart-segments architecture; tests/fixtures/last_30sec.webm ffprobe exit 0; Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md GREEN | PASS |
| 3 | Buffer always contains no more than 30 seconds of video | Phase 1 | src/offscreen/recorder.ts:52-58 MAX_SEGMENTS=3 × 10s = 30s window (D-13 fix-a3 activation 2026-05-15); verified via gsd-verifier audit (Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md row 1 per-requirement scorecard) | PASS |
| 4 | rrweb records DOM events without errors on typical pages | **Phase 3** | **Plan 03-01 A29 GREEN** — 4 EventType-enum checks against rrweb/session.json from probe-HTML-driven archive (Meta=4 + FullSnapshot=2 + IncrementalSnapshot=3 + count > 0); commit cc13f31. T5 override applied per saved memory feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md | PASS (override) |
| 5 | Event log captures clicks, navigation, and network errors | **Phase 3** | **Plan 03-02 A30 GREEN** — 5 UserEvent.type presence checks against logs/events.json (click + input + navigation + js_error + network_error); cs-injection-world pattern via chrome.scripting.executeScript ISOLATED world on https://example.com probe tab; commit 116432a | PASS (override) |
| 6 | Archive download to "Downloads" in < 5 seconds | Phase 2 | Plan 02-04 A25 GREEN — performance.now() bookend + downloadsDir mtime delta both < 5000 ms (commit 47e9818); Plan 02-02 Blob URL pipeline closes audit P0-6 (D-P2-01; commit 79964e6); Phase 2 VERIFICATION.md GREEN | PASS |
| 7 | Archive opens; last_30sec.webm plays back in a browser | Phase 1+2 | Plan 01-08 webm-remux (single EBML; closes D-13 multi-EBML concat unplayability) + operator empirical Chrome playback 2026-05-15; ffmpeg -v warning dry-run exit 0; Plan 02-04 A28 GREEN — 5-entry zip-layout set-equality (commit 20e06a6) | PASS |
| 8 | Passwords do not appear in the log or rrweb snapshots | **Phase 3** | **Plan 03-03 A31 GREEN** — 3-check empirical via cs-injection-world: sentinel absence from logs/events.json (A31.2 + A31.3) + control-input PRESENT (A31.4 defense-in-depth proves listener alive); commit 34b36fb. PARTIAL per D-P3-02 charter (REQ-password-confidentiality Out of Scope v1) | PARTIAL (override) |
| 9 | Extension RAM consumption does not exceed 50 MB in the background | Phase 3+operator | **Plan 03-04 A32 GREEN** (informational; page-realm 1.82 MB observed; SW context excluded per D-P3-04 + RESEARCH Pitfall 2; commit 8c94bd5); **operator chrome://memory-internals verification AWAITED** per D-P3-04 | HUMAN_NEEDED |
### Phase 3 Plan Map
| Plan | Subject | Wave | Outcome |
|-----------|----------------------------------------|------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| 03-01 | rrweb DOM (#4) | 1 | Probe HTML appended + A29 GREEN (4 EventType-enum checks); commits c02914d + cc13f31 |
| 03-02 | event log (#5) | 2 | A30 GREEN (5 UserEvent.type presence checks; cs-injection-world pattern); commits b518101 + 116432a |
| 03-03 | password (#8 PARTIAL) | 3 | A31 GREEN (3 checks: 2 absence + A31.4 defense-in-depth control); commits 8db629f + 34b36fb |
| 03-04 | RAM (#9 best-effort) | 4 | A32 GREEN (host-side Page.metrics scaffolding; page-realm only); commit 8c94bd5 |
| 03-05 | aggregator | 5 | THIS document; REQUIREMENTS.md REQ markers flipped via worktree merge |
## Cross-Cutting Gates
| Gate | Evidence | Status |
|---------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------|
| vitest | 31 files / **171 tests / 171 GREEN** (10.23s; preserved from Phase 2 baseline; no new unit tests in Plans 03-01..04 — all new assertions live in UAT harness tier) | PASS |
| UAT harness | 33 drivers (A0 grep gate + A1..A14 Phase 1 + A15..A17 Plan 01-10 + A18..A22 Plan 01-12 + A23 Plan 01-14 + A24..A28 Plan 02-04 + **A29..A32 Plan 03-01..04**); `HEADLESS=1 SKIP_PROD_REBUILD=1 npm run test:uat` exits 0 with 33/33 GREEN on second consecutive run (first attempt hit pre-existing A29 race-condition flake; documented per 03-02/03-03 SUMMARYs) | PASS |
| Tier-1 grep gate | **12 FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS** (unchanged from Plan 02-04 baseline); `dist/` contains 0 hits for each string; tests/background/no-test-hooks-in-prod-bundle.test.ts 13/13 sub-tests GREEN (4.80s) | PASS |
| Pre-checkpoint bundle gates | Gate 1: `npm run build` exit 0 (2.43s; 9 chunks + manifest). Gate 2: SW CSP — 1 documented setimmediate-polyfill `new Function` in dist/assets/index.ts-8LkXuqac.js (pre-existing per deferred-items.md). Gate 3: SW Node-globals — 0 Buffer/require in SW chunk (index.ts-8LkXuqac.js + index.ts-loader-BmXpFlTx.js). Gate 4: DOM-globals — 3 hits all typeof-guarded (`typeof window`/`typeof document` guards verified). Gate 5: tests/background/sw-bundle-import.test.ts 2/2 GREEN (0.5s). Gate 6: FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS unit 13/13 GREEN. Gate 7: manifest + i18n + build tests 57/57 GREEN (5.14s) — manifest validation + en↔ru parity + build invariants all PASS. | PASS |
| tsc | `npx tsc --noEmit` exit 0 (per Plan 03-04 SUMMARY verification) | PASS |
| Phase 3 surface `as any` / `@ts-ignore` | 0 new instances in tests/uat/lib/harness-page-driver.ts beyond the inherited eslint-disable on the canonical `(window as any).__mokoshHarness` access (matches Plan 02-04 baseline) | PASS |
## Operator-Empirical Acks (verbatim + commit refs)
| Date | Plan | Operator response | Commit |
|--------------|-----------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------|
| _AWAITED_ | 03 (§10 #9 RAM operator check per D-P3-04) | _Pending — operator runs chrome://memory-internals per human_verification block_ | _TBD_ |
*Placeholder row — operator runs chrome://memory-internals per the
human_verification block above; row filled when ack lands. Plan 03-05 closure
does NOT block on this ack — the orchestrator advances Phase 3 once the
documentation marker flips land; the operator ack lands as an addendum commit
when received.*
## Forward-Looking Deferred Items (NOT gaps)
| Item | Owner | Source |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| A29 zip-mtime race-condition flake (chrome-extension:// no-content-script; flaky on ~1/3 runs) | Phase 4 hardening | Plan 03-02 SUMMARY "Issues Encountered" + Plan 03-03 SUMMARY "Issues Encountered" (empirically reproduced 2026-05-20). Recommended fix: re-target A29 to use cs-injection-world pattern (Plan 03-02/03 precedent) |
| Pre-existing parallel-vitest Tier-1-build-step race flake (~1 in 5 full-suite runs; isolated re-run always GREEN) | Phase 4 hardening | Plan 03-03 SUMMARY + Plan 03-04 SUMMARY "Issues Encountered" — verified pre-existing across 03-02/03-03/03-04 |
| rrweb v2 stable upgrade (research + implementation; rrweb-io/rrweb dist-tags `latest=2.0.0-alpha.4` + `alpha=2.0.0-alpha.20`) | Phase 4 hardening | D-P3-03 defer rationale (alpha-pin stable across 9 plans + 33/33 UAT GREEN; semver-major upgrade risk-vs-reward) |
| Programmatic RAM measurement upgrade (per-target `puppeteer.browser.targets()` filter + `createCDPSession()` + `Performance.getMetrics` aggregation across SW + offscreen + page realms; OR chrome.devtools.Memory API) | Phase 4 hardening | D-P3-04 defer rationale (Pitfall 2: SW context separate target; A32 scaffolding ships the page-realm call site as inheritance scaffold) |
| REQ-password-confidentiality v2 candidate (rrweb v2 maskInputFn + data-sensitive HTML attribute guards) | Phase 4 hardening _(conditional)_ | D-P3-02 defer rationale (charter shift 2026-05-20 "we don't care about privacy hardening"); only re-opens if charter reverses |
| A31 extended grep on rrweb/session.json for sentinel absence (one-line extension) | Phase 4 candidate | Plan 03-03 PARTIAL rationale acknowledges this gap if charter reverses |
| Audit P1 #11/#14/#15 polish (fetch Request→[object Request], navigation URL tracking, rrweb timestamp semantics) | Phase 4 hardening | Pre-existing audit backlog (carried from Phase 1 + Phase 2 closure notes) |
| 2 pre-existing ffprobe/ffmpeg vitest flakes (build-dependent + frame-count timeout) | Phase 4 hardening | Plan 01-13 + Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md residual; pre-dates Phase 3 (not introduced by Plans 03-*) |
| getDisplayMedia cursor visibility refinement | Phase 4 hardening | Plan 01-07 operator observation 2026-05-15 (carried in Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md deferred items) |
| Dark-surface logo contrast | Phase 4 hardening | Plan 01-10 operator observation 2026-05-20 (designer follow-up) |
| setimmediate polyfill `new Function` in SW chunk via vite-plugin-node-polyfills | Phase 4 hardening | Plan 01-12 disclosure; `.planning/phases/01-stabilize-video-pipeline/deferred-items.md` |
| ROADMAP backfill for Plans 01-08..01-13 entries | Phase 4 docs polish | Plan 01-13 plan-checker flag #4 (now substantially backfilled in ROADMAP lines 81-87) |
## Re-Verification Status
| Aspect | Status |
|-------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Phase 1 + 2 baselines | UNCHANGED — Plans 03-01..04 add only test-side harness extensions; no production-code edits (`git diff src/` against base 041c4d4 is empty for Plan 03-* commits aside from test/ + .planning/) |
| Production bundle invariant | PRESERVED — FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS at 12 entries; bundle gates 6/6 PASS; SW CSP-safety = 1 documented setimmediate exception; SW Node-globals = 0 hits |
| vitest baseline | PRESERVED — 171/171 GREEN (no new unit tests; no regressions) |
| UAT harness | EXTENDED — 29 → 33 GREEN (+4: A29 rrweb DOM 4-check + A30 event-log 6-check + A31 password absence 3-check + A32 RAM scaffolding 2-check + page-realm-only diagnostic) |
| DEC-011 + Amendment 1 (`tabs` permission) | PRESERVED — Plan 03-* introduces zero new permissions; manifest.json unchanged |
| Saved-memory operating principles | HONORED — feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md drives §10 #4/#5/#8 PARTIAL T5 overrides; feedback-pre-checkpoint-bundle-gates.md drives the 6/6 gate inventory (Task 1) |
**Verified:** 2026-05-20T22:00:00Z (independent gsd-verifier pass over executor-created 03-VERIFICATION.md)
**Status:** human_needed (SPEC §10 #9 RAM genuinely non-automatable + ROADMAP/STATE.md doc-marker gap requires orchestrator action)
**Re-verification:** Yes — independent verifier pass; prior executor-created 03-VERIFICATION.md reviewed and annotated.
---
*Verified: 2026-05-20T19:15:33Z by Claude (gsd-verifier — Phase 3 closure aggregator)*
*Verifier: Plan 03-05 (this document)*
## Verifier Stance and Approach
This report extends and annotates the executor-created 03-VERIFICATION.md (authored by Plan 03-05
at `a63a82117211086c4e976a664fead8e0b6fa0d28`). All claims in the executor document were verified
against the actual codebase. The independent verification:
1. Confirmed all 4 Phase 3 feat commits exist and have correct file scopes
2. Confirmed src/content/index.ts was untouched (D-P3-02 charter; only 1 commit in its history — the initial Phase 1 import)
3. Confirmed REQUIREMENTS.md REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer + REQ-user-event-log show [x] markers
4. Identified the ROADMAP/STATE.md stale-marker gap (known per 03-05-SUMMARY.md worktree protocol)
5. Confirmed FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS stays at 12 entries
6. Confirmed all A29..A32 artifacts exist and are substantive (not stubs)
---
## ROADMAP Success Criteria Verification
Phase 3 ROADMAP.md defines 5 success criteria (lines 199-213). These are verified against codebase HEAD:
| # | ROADMAP SC (verbatim) | Phase Owner | Status | Evidence |
|---|----------------------|-------------|--------|----------|
| SC-1 | Extension installs into Chrome via "Load unpacked" against dist/ with no errors or warnings | Phase 1 (Plan 01-12) | VERIFIED (prior phase) | Operator brand-fit ack 2026-05-20 "all good"; tests/build/no-remote-fonts.test.ts + manifest-i18n.test.ts + locale-parity.test.ts GREEN; Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md GREEN |
| SC-2 | Video buffer runs continuously across tab switches, never > 30 s | Phase 1 | VERIFIED (prior phase) | src/offscreen/recorder.ts D-13 MAX_SEGMENTS=3x10s; A2/A11 harness GREEN; Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md row 1-3 |
| SC-3 | rrweb records on typical page (form+table+modal) without throwing; event log captures clicks/navigation/network errors | Phase 3 | VERIFIED (override) | A29 GREEN cc13f31 (4 EventType checks); A30 GREEN 116432a (5 UserEvent.type checks via cs-injection-world); T5 override per feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md |
| SC-4 | ZIP in Downloads in < 5 s; last_30sec.webm plays | Phase 2 | VERIFIED (prior phase) | A25 <5s empirical (47e9818); A28 zip-layout set-equality (20e06a6); Phase 2 VERIFICATION.md GREEN |
| SC-5 | Background RAM ≤ 50 MB (Chrome Task Manager) | Phase 3 | HUMAN_NEEDED | A32 page-realm scaffold GREEN (8c94bd5; ~1.82 MB); SW context excluded per D-P3-04 + RESEARCH Pitfall 2; operator chrome://memory-internals check required |
**Score: 4/5 SC verified (1 human_needed — SC-5 RAM)**
---
## Requirement Coverage
| Requirement | Phase 3 Plan | Status | Evidence |
|-------------|-------------|--------|----------|
| REQ-install-clean | n/a (Phase 1 closure) | VERIFIED (prior phase) | Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md; REQUIREMENTS.md line 201 [x] marker |
| REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer | 03-01 | VERIFIED (override) | A29 GREEN cc13f31; REQUIREMENTS.md line 54 [x] marker; Traceability row Complete 2026-05-20 |
| REQ-user-event-log | 03-02 | VERIFIED (override) | A30 GREEN 116432a; REQUIREMENTS.md line 74 [x] marker; Traceability row Complete 2026-05-20 |
**All 3 Phase 3 requirement IDs (REQ-install-clean + REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer + REQ-user-event-log) accounted for.**
---
## Observable Truths Verification (from PLAN must_haves)
### Plan 03-01 must_haves (REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| T1 | rrweb session.json contains > 0 events after probe interaction | VERIFIED | A29.2 check; events.length=4 in empirical run (03-01-SUMMARY.md §"A29 empirical evidence") |
| T2 | rrweb emits at least one Meta event (EventType=4) | VERIFIED | A29.3 check GREEN; events include type=4 |
| T3 | rrweb emits at least one FullSnapshot (EventType=2) | VERIFIED | A29.4 check GREEN; events include type=2 |
| T4 | rrweb emits at least one IncrementalSnapshot (EventType=3) after DOM mutation | VERIFIED | A29.5 check GREEN; Pitfall 1 mitigation empirically confirmed (input.value + modal toggle pre-SAVE) |
| T5 | UAT harness 30/30 GREEN | VERIFIED | 03-01-SUMMARY.md; drivers array extended to include A29 in harness.test.ts line 459 |
### Plan 03-02 must_haves (REQ-user-event-log)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| T6 | logs/events.json contains at least one 'click' UserEvent | VERIFIED (override) | A30.2 check GREEN; cs-injection-world ISOLATED injection on https://example.com |
| T7 | logs/events.json contains at least one 'input' UserEvent | VERIFIED (override) | A30.3 check GREEN |
| T8 | logs/events.json contains at least one 'navigation' UserEvent | VERIFIED (override) | A30.4 check GREEN; PopStateEvent dispatch exercises src/content/index.ts:111 |
| T9 | logs/events.json contains at least one 'js_error' UserEvent | VERIFIED (override) | A30.5 check GREEN |
| T10 | logs/events.json contains at least one 'network_error' UserEvent | VERIFIED (override) | A30.6 check GREEN; fetch(404) hits src/content/index.ts:167 ISOLATED-world wrapper |
| T11 | UAT harness 31/31 GREEN | VERIFIED | 03-02-SUMMARY.md; drivers array extended to A30 |
### Plan 03-03 must_haves (§10 #8 PARTIAL)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| T12 | password SENTINEL absent from all UserEvent.value fields | VERIFIED (override, PARTIAL) | A31.2 check GREEN; 0 events contain 'secret-do-not-log-123' |
| T13 | no UserEvent has target === '#probe-password' | VERIFIED (override, PARTIAL) | A31.3 check GREEN |
| T14 | control sentinel PRESENT in at least 1 UserEvent (defense-in-depth) | VERIFIED | A31.4 check GREEN; proves listener alive so A31.2/A31.3 are non-vacuous |
### Plan 03-04 must_haves (§10 #9 best-effort)
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| T15 | Page.metrics returns JSHeapUsedSize value | VERIFIED | A32.1 check GREEN; page-realm heap ~1.82 MB |
| T16 | SW RAM ≤ 50 MB (full extension context) | HUMAN_NEEDED | A32.2 is page-realm only per D-P3-04; SW context requires operator chrome://memory-internals |
**Score: 14/16 truths VERIFIED; 1 VERIFIED (override, PARTIAL); 1 HUMAN_NEEDED**
---
## Required Artifacts Verification
| Artifact | Status | Evidence |
|----------|--------|----------|
| `tests/uat/extension-page-harness.html` (probe HTML) | VERIFIED | probe-form + probe-table + probe-modal-trigger all present (grep -c returns 3); 0 textarea; tokens.css link preserved |
| `tests/uat/extension-page-harness.ts` (assertA29+A30+A31) | VERIFIED | Lines 3363/3517/3788; declare global block lines 3971/3973/3975; __mokoshHarness entries lines 4010/4011/4012 |
| `tests/uat/lib/harness-page-driver.ts` (driveA29+A30+A31+A32) | VERIFIED | driveA29 L1884, driveA30 L2039, driveA31 L2194, driveA32 L2357; EventType import L42; UserEvent import L47 |
| `tests/uat/harness.test.ts` (orchestrator wiring) | VERIFIED | driveA29/A30/A31/A32 imports L101-107; Wrapped consts L344-357; drivers array entries L459/466/479/486; Architecture banner L276 |
| `.planning/phases/03-.../03-VERIFICATION.md` | VERIFIED | 204 lines; frontmatter with status/score/overrides_applied/override_notes/human_verification; 9-criterion scorecard |
| `.planning/REQUIREMENTS.md` (REQ markers) | VERIFIED | REQ-rrweb-dom-buffer [x] marker at L54; REQ-user-event-log [x] marker at L74; Traceability rows L293-294 Complete 2026-05-20 |
| `src/content/index.ts` (UNTOUCHED per D-P3-02) | VERIFIED | git log shows 1 commit only (555eb05 initial import); diff src/ against Phase 3 base is empty |
---
## Key Link Verification
| From | To | Via | Status |
|------|----|-----|--------|
| `harness.test.ts` | `driveA29` in harness-page-driver.ts | import L101 + driveA29Wrapped const L346 + drivers push L459 | VERIFIED |
| `harness.test.ts` | `driveA30` in harness-page-driver.ts | import L103 + driveA30Wrapped const L350 + drivers push L466 | VERIFIED |
| `harness.test.ts` | `driveA31` in harness-page-driver.ts | import L105 + driveA31Wrapped const L356 + drivers push L479 | VERIFIED |
| `harness.test.ts` | `driveA32` in harness-page-driver.ts | import L107 + drivers push L486 (no wrap needed; driveA32 takes only page) | VERIFIED |
| `driveA29` → `assertA29` | page.evaluate harness.assertA29() | L1892 in harness-page-driver.ts | VERIFIED |
| `driveA30` → `assertA30` | page.evaluate harness.assertA30() | L2047 in harness-page-driver.ts | VERIFIED |
| `driveA31` → `assertA31` | page.evaluate harness.assertA31() | L2202 in harness-page-driver.ts | VERIFIED |
| `driveA29` → `@rrweb/types EventType` | `import { EventType } from '@rrweb/types'` | L42 in harness-page-driver.ts | VERIFIED |
| `driveA30` → `src/shared/types.ts UserEvent` | `import type { UserEvent }` | L47 in harness-page-driver.ts | VERIFIED |
| `src/content/index.ts:82` → password filter | `if (target.type === 'password') return;` in setupInputLogging | Line 82 verified in codebase | VERIFIED |
| `src/content/index.ts:285` → rrweb.record() wiring | `record({ emit(event){ rrwebEvents.push(event) }, maskInputOptions: { password: true } })` | Lines 286-309 verified | VERIFIED |
---
## Data-Flow Trace (Level 4)
| Artifact | Data Variable | Source | Status |
|----------|---------------|--------|--------|
| driveA29 rrweb/session.json | events[] | src/content/index.ts rrwebEvents[] populated by rrweb.record() emit; GET_RRWEB_EVENTS round-trip | FLOWING — real rrweb events (4 events empirically observed, types 2+3+4) |
| driveA30 logs/events.json | UserEvent[] | src/content/index.ts addUserEvent() via setupInputLogging + navigation + error + fetch listeners | FLOWING — all 5 types captured via cs-injection-world ISOLATED-world triggers |
| driveA31 logs/events.json | UserEvent[] | same as A30; A31 checks for ABSENCE of password sentinel | FLOWING — negative assertion; control sentinel confirms listener live |
| driveA32 Page.metrics | JSHeapUsedSize | puppeteer.Page.metrics() call | FLOWING (page-realm only; SW excluded by D-P3-04 + RESEARCH Pitfall 2) |
---
## Cross-Cutting Gates
| Gate | Status | Evidence |
|------|--------|----------|
| vitest 171/171 GREEN | VERIFIED | 03-05-SUMMARY.md; 31 test files; 10.23s |
| UAT harness 33/33 GREEN | VERIFIED | 03-05-SUMMARY.md; second consecutive run; first run hit pre-existing A29 zip-mtime flake |
| Tier-1 FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS 12 entries | VERIFIED | harness.test.ts L123-138 verified: exactly 12 entries; 13/13 unit-gate sub-tests GREEN |
| Pre-checkpoint bundle gates 6/6 PASS | VERIFIED | 03-05-SUMMARY.md Task 1: build exit 0 + SW CSP (1 documented setimmediate exception) + Node-globals 0 hits + DOM-globals 3 typeof-guarded + SW-bundle-import 2/2 + FORBIDDEN_HOOK_STRINGS 13/13 + manifest/i18n/build 57/57 |
| tsc --noEmit | VERIFIED | Exit 0 per all 4 plan SUMMARYs |
| src/content/index.ts UNTOUCHED | VERIFIED | Single commit in git history (initial import 555eb05); D-P3-02 charter honored |
| Phase 1 regression | VERIFIED | Plans 03-01..04 add only test-side harness extensions; Phase 1 VERIFICATION.md baseline preserved |
| Phase 2 regression | VERIFIED | Plans 03-01..04 add only test-side harness extensions; Phase 2 VERIFICATION.md baseline preserved |
---
## Anti-Patterns Scan
Scanned: tests/uat/extension-page-harness.ts, tests/uat/lib/harness-page-driver.ts, tests/uat/harness.test.ts (files modified by Phase 3).
| Finding | File | Classification | Impact |
|---------|------|---------------|--------|
| "placeholder" mentions in comments | extension-page-harness.ts (lines 1084, 1086, 2389, 2503, 2517, 2546, 2552) | Info — all refer to "Bug A placeholder icons" in A19 documentation, not code stubs | None — legitimate documentation references |
| One `eslint-disable @typescript-eslint/no-explicit-any` per driveA29/A30/A31 | harness-page-driver.ts lines 1892, 2047, 2202 | Info — documented pattern per Plan 02-04 baseline for page.evaluate context; matches existing A26/A27/A28 precedent | None — matches baseline; no regression |
| A32 page-realm caveat in diagnostics | harness-page-driver.ts line 2364 | Info — intentional informational note per D-P3-04 | None — by design |
No blockers found. No new `__MOKOSH_UAT__`-gated symbols introduced. All Phase 3 code is substantive (not stubs).
---
## Behavioral Spot-Checks
Step 7b: SKIPPED for individual spot-checks (UAT harness requires full Chrome launch; cannot run inline). Harness run evidence accepted from SUMMARY.md records per feedback-trust-harness-over-manual-uat.md delegation pattern — the 03-01 through 03-05 SUMMARYs each record verbatim UAT exit codes and assertion traces.
Evidence of last confirmed harness run: 03-05-SUMMARY.md §"vitest baseline preserved" + §"UAT harness 33/33 GREEN on second consecutive run" (vitest 171/171 GREEN at 10.23s; UAT 33/33 GREEN).
---
## Human Verification Required
### 1. SPEC §10 #9 — Extension background RAM ≤ 50 MB
**Test:** Load extension from dist/ into Chrome (Load unpacked). Start a recording. Leave idle ≥ 5 minutes. Open chrome://memory-internals OR chrome://extensions → Service worker link → DevTools Memory tab. Find Mokosh extension entry. Read the "Service worker" memory value.
**Expected:** Total extension background RAM < 50 MB.
**Why human:** puppeteer.Page.metrics() is page-realm only (RESEARCH Pitfall 2). MV3 service worker is a separate V8 isolate not accessible via page.metrics(). A32 (8c94bd5) provides informational page-realm scaffold (~1.82 MB) but this does not close §10 #9.
**Operator reply contract:** Type "approved §10 #9 — observed RAM <X> MB" or describe deviation. Route deviation via /gsd-debug per feedback-gsd-ceremony-for-fixes.md.
### 2. ROADMAP/STATE.md marker flip (doc-only orchestrator action)
**Test:** Verify ROADMAP.md line 37 (`- [ ] **Phase 3:`) is updated to `[x]` with a CLOSED 2026-05-20 citation. Verify the Progress table row 3 status column updated. Verify STATE.md `completed_phases: 2` incremented to `3`.
**Expected:** ROADMAP Phase 3 row shows [x] with closure note; STATE.md completed_phases: 3.
**Why human:** Explicitly deferred to orchestrator per parallel-executor worktree protocol (documented in 03-05-SUMMARY.md key-decisions; same pattern as Phase 2 closure). This is a doc-only gap — all code and test artifacts are fully delivered.
---
## Gaps Summary
No code gaps. The ROADMAP/STATE.md stale markers are the only pending items. These are:
- **Known and intentional** per the 03-05-SUMMARY.md worktree-aware parallel-executor protocol
- **Not blocking** Phase 3 goal achievement (all code, test artifacts, and requirement markers are complete)
- **Requiring orchestrator action** to flip the two doc markers (ROADMAP Phase 3 progress table + STATE.md completed_phases)
The executor-created 03-VERIFICATION.md was substantively accurate. This independent verification report:
- Confirms all artifact claims with direct codebase evidence
- Adds ROADMAP SC-level verification (5 criteria vs the 9-criterion SPEC §10 scorecard)
- Annotates the ROADMAP/STATE.md gap as a WARNING requiring orchestrator action
- Elevates status from `passed` to `human_needed` due to SC-5 RAM criterion + ROADMAP doc gap
---
## Forward-Looking Deferred Items (not gaps — carried from executor's VERIFICATION.md)
| Item | Owner |
|------|-------|
| A29 zip-mtime race flake (~1/3 runs); fix: cs-injection-world re-target | Phase 4 hardening |
| Programmatic SW-realm RAM measurement (puppeteer.browser.targets() + CDP per-target) | Phase 4 hardening |
| rrweb v2 stable upgrade research (alpha-pin stable through Phase 3) | Phase 4 hardening |
| REQ-password-confidentiality v2 (rrweb maskInputFn + data-sensitive guards) | Phase 4 conditional |
| A31 extended: grep rrweb/session.json for sentinel absence (one-line ext.) | Phase 4 candidate |
| Pre-existing parallel-vitest Tier-1-build-step race (~1/5 full-suite runs) | Phase 4 hardening |
| Audit P1 #11/#14/#15 polish (fetch Request→[object Request], nav URL, rrweb timestamps) | Phase 4 hardening |
| 2 pre-existing ffprobe/ffmpeg vitest flakes | Phase 4 hardening |
| getDisplayMedia cursor visibility refinement | Phase 4 hardening |
| Dark-surface logo contrast | Phase 4 hardening |
| setimmediate polyfill `new Function` in SW chunk (pre-existing) | Phase 4 hardening |
| ROADMAP backfill for Plans 01-08..01-13 | Phase 4 docs polish |
---
_Verified: 2026-05-20T22:00:00Z_
_Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier — independent pass over executor-created 03-VERIFICATION.md)_
_Prior executor VERIFICATION.md: a63a82117211086c4e976a664fead8e0b6fa0d28 (docs(03-05): Task 2)_