Validates iter-3 polish revision of Plan 04-08 (commit 17e55dd) against
iter-2 PASSED verdict (1 WARNING + 4 cosmetic-advisories).
Resolution status:
- iter-2 NEW WARNING (displaySurface sub-gate scope): RESOLVED via clean
drop of --check-display-surface-only mode; HIGH-LATENCY catch path
locked in (spike re-run's assertA2 fast-fail).
- iter-2 cosmetic-advisory 1 (collectDistFiles symbol mismatch):
RESOLVED — replaced with listAllFilesRecursive(DIST_DIR) +
countOccurrencesInFile at correct line numbers (152, 185, 133).
- iter-2 cosmetic-advisory 2 (WARNING 1 SUMMARY-write practice):
RESOLVED — inline comment at code snippet (lines 730-737) + Step 6
SUMMARY content list bullet.
- iter-2 cosmetic-advisory 3 (vitest math 183 -> 184): RESOLVED —
anchored to Tier-2 test block in 5 locations consistently.
- iter-2 cosmetic-advisory 4 (duration=N/A rationale): PARTIALLY
RESOLVED — added to SUMMARY content list with forward-pointer from
PLAN body; in-body reasoning preserved (planner's "moved" claim
language slightly overstates the change but end-state behavior is
fine).
Two NEW iter-3 cosmetic-advisories (NON-BLOCKING):
1. recorder.ts:294 mis-citation — actual displaySurface throw is at
lines 313-321 (line 294 is a comment block). Off by ~25 lines but
unambiguous; only one wrong-display-surface throw exists in
recorder.ts. Executor will land on the right gate.
2. duration=N/A "moved" framing vs preserved+forward-ref'd reality —
revision_history claim language slightly overstates; end-state fine.
Pre-execution validation: gsd-sdk verify.plan-structure returns
valid=true; both tasks have files+action+verify+done; 14 frontmatter
fields including revision_history with all three iters logged.
Pure polish pass: +51/-22 lines on PLAN.md only; no thesis edits, no
scope changes, BLOCKER fixes from iter-2 preserved verbatim.
Verdict: PASSED-WITH-RESIDUAL (0 BLOCKER + 0 WARNING + 2 cosmetic-
advisories). Both residuals are documentation-cosmetic (line-number
citation + framing-of-iter-3-polish-claim); orchestrator's call between
immediate execution OR optional iter-4. Recommended: PROCEED to execute
Plan 04-08.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
